show

Ernest Beck

State of Shelter


Patrick Wharram's Lightweight Emergency Shelter. Rendering courtesy Design 21: Social Design Network.

As aid and relief supplies reach Haiti to help earthquake victims, attention is focusing on immediate needs such as food, water, medical care and temporary shelter. Shelter plays a critical role in emergency relief as a way not only to protect victims from weather conditions but also to provide a semblance of family and community life amid horrific conditions and collapsed infrastructure.

For the most part, aid organizations still rely on old standbys like tents and tarps for emergency shelters. They are cheap and easy to transport and set up, and although basic, they work well for immediate shelter even in precarious conditions such as post-earthquake Haiti. “Nothing beats the price point of a blue tarp,” notes Deborah Gans, of Gans Studio, a New York architecture firm that has worked in the area of disaster relief housing.

There are new and innovative alternatives to tarps and tents, which have been developed over the past decade following disasters ranging from the Asian tsunami to Katrina and earthquakes in Pakistan, China and Iran. These designs use new lightweight materials, or sandbags or indigenous materials such as repackaged clay or earth. They also incorporate clever folding and packaging methods.

But the new designs have drawbacks: they are usually more expensive than tarps and tents; they have not been widely field-tested; and they are not kept in inventory in large numbers, which means overwhelmed aid agencies can’t rely on a rapid deployment. Moreover, while the newer designs can be used for prompt emergency housing they are often better suited for the second stage of relief known as transitional housing, between emergency shelters and permanent settlement.



Steps for setting up Concrete Canvas Shelter. Photos courtesy Concrete Canvas.

Compared to soft solutions like tarps and tents, the recently launched Concrete Canvas Shelters — rapidly deployable hardened shelters made from a cement-impregnated fabric — are robust and solid structures that can be erected in a few hours (all you need is water and a generator for the air pump). But they cost around $24,500 for a 270-square-foot unit, and because it is a new technology, developed by the British company Concrete Canvas, supplies are limited. Originally developed for military use and as field hospitals, concrete shelters are “probably not appropriate for Haiti as short term housing but as a replacement for infrastructure, such as for hospitals and field operations,” explains Peter Brewin, the company’s operations manager.


Deborah Gans's Roll Out House. Rendering courtesy Gans Studio.

Concrete canvas shelters are not as expensive as the notorious FEMA trailer, used for years after Katrina to house the displaced, which cost around $67,000 each. A less expensive way to go might be Gans’s Roll Out House, made of two infrastructural columns, one of folded paper and one of bamboo, which support a roof that collects water and is equipped with photovoltaic cells. The core house could be delivered for “several hundred dollars,” Gans says, but the design, originally developed for Kosovo refugees, has never been put into production.

Prefab structures, like Global Village Shelters, are another option. These are solid, waterproof structures are made of extruded polypropylene and shipped as flat packs. Small 65-square-foot units cost around $1,000 when ordered in bulk, but they take up to eight weeks to manufacture. Still, Dan Ferrara, founder of Global Village Shelters, says one benefit of these shelters over tents is that their sturdiness “provides a sense of home.”


Global Village Shelters. Photo courtesy Global Village Shelters.

Patrick Wharram’s Lightweight Emergency Shelter, which won first prize in a competition on the design for social change site Design21, is easy to transport and erect and has a sustainable element — it’s made of recyclable polyester mesh and aluminum, so it can be reused or recycled when the emergency is over. What’s more, the foldable framework and polyester material are sewn together to form a single unit. That means no loose components that could get lost; setup is easy. “The whole shelter is one piece that concertinas out from its packed state and locks into rigid form,” Wharram, a freelance designer, explains. “In a natural disaster like in Haiti, the last thing rescue workers or locals need to be concerned with is erecting a shelter that is complicated to assemble.”

Unfortunately, the Lightweight Emergency Shelter is not yet in production (a prototype is expected this year). That’s too late to help the people of Haiti, who will have to make do right now with tarps and tents as their temporary homes as they start to rebuild their lives.


Posted in: Disaster Relief, Shelter

Comment 30  |     |     |   Like 0  |   Tweet 0
Comments [30]
Please add the Hexayurt (url above) to this page. Thank you!
Vinay Gupta
01.19.10
01:40

I was thinking about this issue last night. I wasn't so much thinking about the myriad ways that designers and manufacturers have been developing temporary disaster structures, there are a lot of great ideas out there, what I thought about and what got me a bit angry is that it seems that all the work that went into this post-Katrina and post-tsunami are still just a lot of great ideas.

Have any of these options been deployed? Have any NGO's, and/or governmental organizations been serious about listening to the design community? Conversely have designers been listening to aid organizations to reduce costs, manufacturing processes' and delivery systems? Just curious if anyone has any information about test cases to put anything like the options discussed into use.

Thanks.
Mark Kaufman
01.19.10
03:55

Mark, I could write volumes about what I have learned trying to actually launch housing solution from the ground up. However, I am going to exercise great restriantant here to follow Design Observer's comment policy of keeping thing short.

My personal experience over the past 5 years since Katrina has boiled down to several key findings or hard lessons learned by a designer:

1. You can not design for the "greater good" and expect it to go anywhere on merit alone. The "greater good" is broke. That is to say, you can not just solve the problem and expect it to go anywhere with a solid business case and profit projections – no matter how brilliant the solution is.

2. Solutions for promotion vs. real solutions over the years has also been an issue. Mark, you are right there have been tons of solutions since Katrina around housing and virtually none have been built. I would like to propose that the majority of them were not serious attempts to solve the problem but as an exercise within design/architecture studios which where then submitted to every design publication for promotion. This effectively created a wall of noise making it hard for the legitimate solutions to be filtered out of this. This makes marketing a solution very difficult - especially if you are an individual. My system really only got traction once I joined frog design and they attached their name to it. My housing solution coming from this one designer that no one has ever heard of, made it extremely hard to compete for headlines against staritects and their brain farts. Core77 has turned me down because my solutions was not "fresh" meaning housing systems by designers have been covered already.

3. The government views housing as "insurance". I have literally been told by one senator's chief of staff that "son, you better hope for another hurricane to roll in, because you are just selling insurance".

4. Most aid organizations and NGO's do not develop products. They do not offer grants to have products developed. They only procure supplies and run inventories of those supplies. Housing system components (even tent like options) take up a lot more shelf space than MREs. So, this leaves it back up to individuals to bet the farm so to speak on their solution and develop it with the hope that NGO's will have the budget to buy it so they can recoup their expenses (not talking profits here).

5. Existing manufactures that could easy step laterally into selling housing systems for disaster relief need strong business cases, market research, and profit projections. The manufactures I have talked to expect the designer to bring all of that home work with them. So, not only do you have to solve the problem, you have to get your hands dirty as to how someone else will make massive profits from your idea. It gets to be a dirty feeling, at least for me, at this point when your original goal was only to those in need.

I go on and on but I am jaded and tired. I hope this helps clarify Mark. As for talking with NGOs in regards to their needs - have you ever tried to set up a meeting like that? Believe me as an unknown designer, no one calls back or puts you through to the person with the calendar.

-michael
Michael McDaniel
01.20.10
10:56

Michael,

Thank you so much for taking the time to respond. I know it must have been hard to restrain yourself in recounting your frustrations in attempting to bring real world solutions to the fantasy world of design and architecture for the greater good. I truly appreciate your struggles and the problems that you laid out here. It is pretty much as I suspected as an outsider in product design, when it comes to aid organizations, manufacturers and government. Unfortunately the saddest indictment that you make is in your assessment of promotion v. solution, "See how clever we are, see how much we care, see how fast we are moving on to a featured spot at the TED conference.

Thanks again for your attempt to transcend this insurmountable problem. I only wish that a design conference somewhere would invite you to speak on this side of the issue of Design for the Greater Good.

Cheers.
Mark Kaufman
01.20.10
04:28

Mark,

You are missing one of the most promising temporary housing designs of the decade: check out the Reaction system, by designer Michael McDaniel; http://www.protectthehuman.com/videos/reaction-housing

Best Wishes,
Robert
Robert A. Bernardini
01.21.10
12:44

I was already familiar with Michael's design and system. My concern and initial question was that these new and promising housing solutions have not been able to make the leap from “Hey!, that's a great idea” to production and implementation.

Michael was gracious enough to relate his story in the comment above mine.
Mark Kaufman
01.22.10
07:58

      It is such a sad story. A lot of people in Haiti died and many other people should be helped. If new and innovative shelters are used for victims in Haiti, recovering Haiti disaster will be going smoothly and fast. Helping victims is much more important than any economic value but, in the long term, economic value isn’t abandoned for better ideas and solution. It is a kind of problem of realistic value and idealistic value.
Yeonkyu Park
01.24.10
09:40

Michael

What kind of material(s) were used to fabricate the EXO? Looking at your design makes me wonder about the ventilation and VOC's. I'm sure you've consider all this, but I was curious. I think the concept is great. I like the reference to IKEA in your video. Everything needs to be modular and flexible in adapting to a disaster environment. With all the military bases that have closed over the years, I would think most cities, counties and states with programs implemented for Emergency Preparedness like the San Francisco Bay Area could utilized these bases for storage.

David Hayashida
02.22.10
03:10

In the U.S. and around the world, aid organizations are walking a fine line, trying to encourage skilled professionals who can provide indispensable assistance — and waving off those who might not be up to the task.
Rakesh
06.29.10
02:43

The concrete canvas emergency housing seems like a brilliant idea. I think costs should come down once the company is more established and receives contracts. I think Haiti would be an excellent place as well as many parts of Africa for this type of housing. This type of housing also seems more secure and suitable for storing rations and medicine.

critical care jobs
Aaron
07.09.10
03:39

The innovation that springs from times like these can do nothing but increase the breadth of our work as designers and practitioners. One thing to keep in mind is security and maintenance. I am sure there are many desperate people on the ground and their security has got to be paramount. Long term stability of these structures would also be very helpful. Good for all of the innovative thoughts.
Jess Hernandez
08.31.10
06:31

You really make it seem so easy with your presentation but I find this topic to be really something which I think I would never understand. It seems too complicated and very broad for me. I am looking forward for your next post, I will try to get the hang of it!
thalasso pas cher
12.15.10
09:06

I was very pleased to find this site. I wanted to thank you for this great read!! I definitely enjoyed every little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to check out the new stuff you post.
Mary Ann
03.01.11
10:52

The designs and the make over relief shelters designed and conceptualized by Patrick Wharram are better ones than that are presently available to peoples in relief camps.These shelters are alike real home and are fully comfort oriented and also well ventilated that can be very suitable for people to stay in it.dr marlene
ernest678
04.13.11
08:38

What a timely and relevant article in light of the recent tsunami in Japan. I wonder if structures similar to these were used in the relief effort? They do look like a great alternative to canvas tents.

Linda Wilburn
My travel blog - Golf Resorts
Linda Wilburn
04.17.11
01:55

I was just think of this issued about the shelter problems for the victims of natural calamities, really these are massive collections of well planned housing schemes for the victims, in recently we have recognized a disaster earthquake in Japan, I think these shelter are provides a drawbacks and option for those kind of disaster victims, really these are the best housing designs of the decades.
acid alkaline diet review
SANDERS2004
04.22.11
03:29

I was already familiar with Michael's design and system. My concern and initial question was that these new and promising housing solutions have not been able to make the leap from “Hey!, that's a great idea” to production and implementation.
love quotes
watch free movies online
sagarbunkar1984
04.22.11
07:17

Shelter problems are always arise for the victims of natural calamities, they are usually suffers a lot form this issues but while go through sorts details provide in this post I was just a bit of sure that most of problems are solved through the help of these emergencies housing designs, which includes many features with advanced techniques made while keeping the interest of the victims.
wine bar brooklyn
George868
10.05.11
08:23

this is really a nice post.I really like the way you start and conclude your thoughts. Thank you so much for this information.
nobelboy
03.02.12
06:27

The relief shelters designed by Patrick Wharram are better ones than that are presently available to peoples in relief camps. These shelters are alike real home and are fully comfort oriented. Shelter plays a critical role in emergency relief such as to protect victims from weather conditions and provide a assurance of family and community life.
Alberta watson
03.15.12
07:07

I was just completely aware of these issues that how peoples are facing more problems at the time of being evicted from their house during the time of disasters, but here we found a perfect solution for these kinds of problems its really a impressive format of house.
outback coupons
chasecooper737
03.28.12
05:45

Shelter is play most important role in natural disaster, at natural calamity we can use it for relief the person those who are affected and keep them in side shelter for food, water, medical care etc. definitely it is essential to protect the victims from disaster.
jordge stephenson
03.29.12
03:15

The issues of shelter are being noticed at the time of natural disaster when people suffered to get a better facilities of housing schemes, therefore I think these features are quite awesome offers a great source and techniques such as replacing these houses from one place to another. Really appreciable.
michealblake596
04.26.12
01:31

Previously I have been known about state of shelters which are seems to be in the form of concrete houses but here we came to know that shelters are also made from some exceptional works with latest facilities, features and also easily move from one place to another. I was fully impress by these concepts of providing shelters to the victims.
crishtoperdaniel
05.10.12
07:27

In Haiti the main attentions for focusing on basic and essential needs are food water and shelter and here we found a great and advanced review of the shelter issues, these shelter programs are really proclaims the whole importance through it's advanced features and characters. I was fully impressed by it's features.
Brook457
05.16.12
07:05

Shelter is most essential for meet the challenge like natural disaster. Of course the issue is very well. We can provide shelter and primary treatment, food, water for victim. I am deeply impressed at your work. But shelter design should be economical.
keith stephenson
05.22.12
02:19

The standard of living are being change in a huge differences, and the issues of shelter programs are also being changed in digital way as here noticed with the advanced features of high profile made houses for the victims of Haiti earthquake, these are graph as the most expensive rate of shelter including high efficiency of techniques.
Pierce Morkel
05.22.12
07:30

It was a great initiative, but that Haiti issue was a little hectic, all sorts of things were going on during that incident. There were Americans going to Haiti and literally adopting the children, I guess I'm not 100% on the specifics, but it was a little odd to me. Anyway, I'm glad its over and I hope neighbouring countries will help Haiti to grow into a great country. Movies To Download
Rodger
06.08.12
01:29

I have suspected the same thing before and after reading your posts, I now know that my suspicions have basis. I have read a couple of the articles on your web site since yesterday, and I truly like your style of blogging. I added it to my favorites blog list and will be checking back soon. Please visit my site too and let me know your opinion.
Nina88
09.05.12
05:14

In the past I have been recognized about talk about of possess which can be appears to be such as real residences but the following many of us located understand that possess can Garcinia cambogia also be constructed from a few excellent works together most recent establishments, attributes and also quickly move in one destination to yet another. We had been entirely make an impression on simply by these kind of aspects of offering possess for the subjects.
shahbaz123
06.26.14
03:22



Creative Opportunities
  • Twitter Facebook Google+
    Tumblr Pinterest RSS

    Design Observer
    social media à la carte
  • Newsletter signup

  • Design Jobs
    Observer Jobs Spotlight




Places Journal