show

Rob Walker

Crowdcrit vs. Apple Maps


The debate over the relative merits of “amateur” (or “citizen,” if you like) critics has meandered on for more than a decade now. Still, there’s a subset of the genre that deserves more attention: you could call it the crowd critique — or let’s just be snappy and say crowdcrit. It roared into view last week in response to Apple’s new iOS 6 Maps app.


“That big green blob is in a 5th Avenue bus lane,” via The Amazing iOS 6 Maps

Professional critics of course responded to this alternative to Google Maps now being foisted on iOS users — Slate has a a largely negative assessment here, for instance. But the most crushing, and practically instantaneous, critique emerged in the form of a submission-driven Tumblr, The Amazing iOS 6 Maps (“The Apple iOS 6 Maps are amazing. Not”), offering a barrage of glitches, errors, and failures that users have found in scrutinizing the new Maps. As Xeni Jardin observed: “You know you have an issue when someone brews up a Tumblr to mock you.” Very true. This Tumblr began on Thursday and a glance at its archive makes it clear that there was plenty to post from the get-go. Not surprisingly, the Slate review bolstered its case with examples culled from the Tumblr, as well as a Twitter hashtag (#MapsFail). “Users Blast Maps Switch,” the lead story in Friday’s Wall Street Journal announced.

But can a Tumblr collecting scads of images from far-flung contributors, with very little text and no real attempt at traditional analysis, really be considered a form of “criticism”? Yes. And in this case the result is surprisingly enjoyable, as some of the glitches have produced accidentally pleasing surrealist cityscapes — a monstrous green shape seems to menace Fifth Avenue, Interstate 10 buckles toward cubism, airport runways undulate, and the application informs us that gas stations can be found atop Houston skypscrapers. 

 

Highway challenge, via The Amazing iOS 6 Maps

 

“Those are corporate headquarters, not gas stations,” via The Amazing iOS 6 Maps

This instance certainly demonstrates that crowdcrit can offer an extremely persuasive critique, overwhelming in its specific examples on a level no single pro could hope to match. (It might even be unfairly persuasive: You can find built-environment impossibilities through Google, too, as this Amazing iOS 6 Maps post notes. Clement Vella offers up some beguiling examples collected from Google Earth in this piece for Rhizome. That said, many of the Tumblr’s examples are more straightforward instances of practical geographic mistakes.)

“Terrain maps don’t know where structures are,” via The Amazing iOS 6 Maps.

One of the most productive assessments of the non-pro criticism the Web makes possible appeared, as it happens, in these (Web)pages: Alice Twemlow, in 2010, pointed to a funny Amazon review of a cat toilet as an example of “a democratizing impulse in design criticism” — democratizing in terms of what gets critiqued as well as who gets to be a critic. I want to push a little further by de-emphasizing the importance of any individual author in such cases; crowdcrit is effective partly because its authorship is diffuse, collective, and accretive. In fact the more abstract the authorship gets, the more effective the results can be.

This would make crowdcrit difficult to anthologize, of course, but it’s a thing to be reckoned with just the same. Admittedly, many prior instances I can think of tend to involve obscurities. But I’d argue that, say, the deluge of absurd Amazon reviews for a “banana slicer” has a kind of critical value, making a statement about how bizarre and nonsensical product culture can get, and doing so as well as any pro critic could (at least any pro critic limited to making the point solely by addressing a banana slicer). A crowdcrit assault on “Bic For Her” pens underlined the stupidity and offensiveness of object-gendering; it’s hard to miss the  point of complaints on the pricing of a Hasselblad served up by crowdcrit; and so on. (And aside from Apple's Maps, another example of a non-obscure crowdcrit victim: The Bible.)


“Prepare for some turbulence,” via  The Amazing iOS 6 Maps

Given all the recent debate about how negative critics should or shouldn’t be, it’s notable that crowdcrit is all about the devastating takedown. Or is it? Surely Three Wolf Moon is crucial to this genre’s canon, and in that case the apparent mockery made the object a beloved and desirable (well, to some) artifact. This connects crowdcrit to ROFLculture (a subject for another time) but also brings us back to the anti-Maps Tumblr, which in addition to making a highly convincing critical case, is both imaginative and pleasurable. You really don't have to care one way or the other about iPhone software to be drawn in by the uncanny imagery the site collects. 

Here, I would say, crowdcrit has it over the takedowns offered by most pros, which certainly can be intrinsically entertaining, but frequently aren’t. Not that I’m against takedowns, per se: I just find it more impressive when someone finds a way to creatively destroy a deserving target. I think that’s a noble goal, and that crowdcrit has offered us some pretty inspiring examples of reaching it. 

Oh, and P.S.: Swiss Miss has pointed out a workaround for getting Google Maps back on your iOS 6 desktop, here.

 



Posted in: Interaction Design, Internet, Theory + Criticism

Comment 7  |     |     |   Like 17  |   Tweet 93
Rob Walker Rob Walker is a technology and culture columnist for Yahoo News. He is the former Consumed columnist for The New York Times Magazine, and has contributed to many publications. He is co-editor (with Joshua Glenn) of the book Significant Objects: 100 Extraordinary Stories About Ordinary Things, and author of Buying In: The Secret Dialogue Between What We Buy and Who We Are.

MORE
Comments [7]





Apple ‘apologizes’ for bust!

Yea, I google searched for a formal apology from Apple for the ripping off my “built-in” google maps app with iOS 6 and all I found was an apology from rock star Fiona Apple. Yea, I did the Swiss-Miss fix but it is not the same. As a loyal fan of both companies, I think Apple & Google should have worked out a deal.
Carl W. Smith
09.27.12
09:52


From . . . Criminal by Fiona Apple


What I need is a good defense

'Cause I'm feelin' like a criminal

And I need to be redeemed

To the one I've sinned against

Because
. . . crowdcrit’s . . . all I ever knew of love

                                    

What a difference a day makes.

Tim Cook proved that he is a stand up guy! And the Crowd critique might say Apple is redeemed. Cook said today in a formal Apple apology posted on the company’s web site. “With the launch of our new Maps last week, we fell short on this commitment. We are extremely sorry for the frustration this has caused our customers and we are doing everything we can to make Maps better.”



Thank you, Rob.
Carl W. Smith
09.28.12
11:31

Carl W. Smith
09.29.12
09:44

Thanks, Carl. And yeah, a full-on Apple apology, that's not exactly an everyday occurrence. Score one for crowdcrit?
Rob Walker
09.30.12
11:38

Yeah!
Score one for crowdcrit, Rob Walker and Tim Cook.
Apple is redeemed.

PS Yea = A misspelling of the word "yeah" which means "yes!"
Mea culpa.
Carl W. Smith
09.30.12
12:52

Hello, this is very nice blog. I really found such great information here related to smart phones.

for more

http://www.itechwhiz.com/2012/09/iphone5-vs-galaxy-s3-vs-iphone4s-vs-lumia920.html
farhanmalikseo
10.03.12
07:50

Well this is something I have been trying to create for a while though mine didn’t come out exactly like Thank you for this tutorial.
Sila Mahmud
10.04.12
01:26



Creative Opportunities
  • Twitter Facebook Google+
    Tumblr Pinterest RSS

    Design Observer
    social media à la carte
  • Newsletter signup

  • Design Jobs
    Observer Jobs Spotlight